A Complete Guide to Polishing an Aluminum Boat

At a glance

Polishing an aluminum boat starts with a thorough wash and careful masking, then uses the least aggressive compound and pad that correct the oxidation. Refine the finish, wipe away residue, and apply a compatible marine wax or sealant.

  • Match the method and compound to the hull condition.
  • Clean, degrease, inspect, and mask before polishing.
  • Finish with a compatible protective coating.

Polishing an aluminum boat does more than improve its appearance. A specialized abrasive compound removes the dull, chalky oxidation layer and restores a smoother finish. Because bare aluminum begins oxidizing again after polishing, apply a compatible marine wax or sealant afterward for protection, especially on boats used in saltwater.

Why Polishing Your Aluminum Boat Matters

 

Before and after comparison of a boat hull, showing a dull, weathered side and a shiny, polished side.

 

Polishing is not purely cosmetic. Bare aluminum reacts with oxygen and forms a dull layer of aluminum oxide. That oxide layer offers some natural protection, but deposits and prolonged exposure to harsh conditions can contribute to uneven oxidation and pitting.

Polishing is how we physically grind off that oxidized layer to reveal the fresh, vibrant metal hiding underneath.

Regular inspection, cleaning, polishing when needed, and a protective topcoat help maintain the finish and make developing corrosion easier to spot.

The Science of Shine and Protection

Salt, moisture, and sun are hard on a boat's hull. Polishing smooths the aluminum surface, while the wax or sealant applied afterward provides the protective layer.

This simple act of preventative maintenance pays off in several ways:

  • Corrosion Care: A smooth, sealed surface is easier to rinse free of water and salt. For more detail, see our guide to fighting salt corrosion on boats.
  • Easier Cleaning: Grime, algae, and salt deposits are generally easier to wash from a smooth, polished hull than from a rough, oxidized one.
  • Better Presentation: A clean, well-cared-for finish can make the boat more appealing to prospective buyers.

A consistent maintenance schedule can reduce the need for aggressive correction later. Inspect the hull for pitting or structural damage rather than assuming polishing will correct it.

A Schedule for Success

Inspect the finish regularly and polish only when cleaning no longer restores it. Saltwater exposure, storage, weather, and the existing protective coating all affect the interval, so follow the polish and sealant manufacturers' directions rather than relying on a fixed schedule.

A freshly polished aluminum surface does more than improve dockside appearance. The process smooths minor surface irregularities and leaves the hull easier to inspect and clean. Do not expect polishing alone to produce a measurable change in fuel use or performance.

Choosing Your Polishing Tools and Compounds

 

Various tools and supplies for polishing a boat are neatly arranged on a wooden dock.

 

Having the right equipment is what separates a frustrating, weekend-long chore from a genuinely satisfying project. When you're staring down a dull aluminum hull, the tools and compounds you pick will make all the difference in the final shine and the effort it takes to get there.

The first big decision is an easy one: are you going to tackle this job by hand, or with a machine?

Hand Polishing Versus Machine Polishing

Gloved boat owner using a machine polisher on an aluminum hull
Choose hand or machine polishing to suit the job.

Honestly, this choice often comes down to the boat's condition and how much time you've got. Polishing with aluminum polish by hand is great for small jon boats, hitting tight spots around cleats and railings, or just doing a quick touch-up. It gives you incredible control but requires a serious amount of elbow grease for an entire hull.

For most folks, especially if you're dealing with a larger boat or any significant oxidation, a machine is the only way to go. It’s faster, more effective, and delivers that professional-grade gleam you're after.

  • Hand Polishing: Your best bet for light oxidation and detail work. It’s less aggressive, which lowers the risk of marring the aluminum, but it's a slow and steady process.
  • Machine Polishing: The undisputed champion for moderate to heavy oxidation. A good variable-speed orbital buffer makes quick work of large areas and has the muscle to cut through that chalky buildup for a true mirror finish.

The key takeaway here is to match the method to the mission. Don't even think about hand-polishing a heavily oxidized 22-foot pontoon unless you're looking for a multi-day workout. A quality orbital buffer is a fantastic investment for any serious boat owner.

Assembling Your Polishing Arsenal

Alright, once you’ve picked your path, hand or machine, it's time to gather the gear. Using the right supplies doesn't just make the work easier; it's essential for getting that coveted mirror finish without accidentally damaging your boat.

To help you get organized, here’s a quick-reference table of the essentials for both polishing methods.

Essential Toolkit for Aluminum Boat Polishing

Item Purpose Hand Polishing Machine Polishing Better Boat Recommendation
Variable-Speed Orbital Buffer Powers through oxidation and buffs large surfaces quickly. Not Needed Essential Look for a reputable brand with ergonomic design.
Wool Compounding Pads Aggressive cutting for heavy oxidation removal. Not Needed Essential Use with your cutting compound for the first pass.
Foam Polishing/Finishing Pads Removes swirl marks and creates a high-gloss shine. Not Needed Essential A softer pad for the final polishing step.
Applicator Pads Applying compound and polish by hand. Essential Good for tight spots Soft foam or the Microfiber Wax Applicator Set works best.
Cutting Compound Abrasive polish to remove the top layer of oxidation. Essential Essential Use a heavy-cut aluminum compound for heavy oxidation, then finish with Marine Aluminum Polish.
Finishing Polish Fine abrasive polish to refine the surface to a mirror shine. Essential Essential For a two-step process, follow the cutting compound to remove hazing.
High-Quality Microfiber Towels Wiping away residue without scratching the surface. Essential Essential Better Boat Microfiber Cloth Set 12Pk

This list covers the non-negotiables. You'll thank yourself later for not skimping, especially on good microfiber towels, cheap ones will just leave lint and fine scratches behind.

Demystifying Polishing Compounds

The polish itself is the real magic in a bottle. Not all polishes are created equal, and using the wrong one will leave you with a hazy, swirled mess that's worse than when you started.

Pro tip. Start with the least aggressive compound that corrects the oxidation. Pair it with the pad intended for that stage.

For bare aluminum, reach for a polish made specifically for the material rather than a general-purpose automotive compound.

Marine Aluminum Polish

Better Boat pick

Marine Aluminum Polish

Bring back shine on bare aluminum pontoons, jon boats, canoes, and hardware after cleaning or restoration.

View product

Think of it this way: different surfaces require different levels of abrasion. You wouldn't use the same approach on every material, and understanding concepts from other fields, like professional glass polishing techniques, shows how specific abrasive properties are key to success.

For aluminum boat hulls, you'll almost always need a two-step combo:

  1. Cutting Compound: This is the heavy lifter. It's a more aggressive polish with larger abrasives designed to slice through that tough, chalky layer of oxidation and level the surface.
  2. Finishing Polish: Once the grunt work is done, you follow up with a fine finishing polish. This removes the microscopic scratches and swirls left by the cutting compound, bringing out that brilliant, deep shine.

Choosing the right product can feel overwhelming, but we've got you covered. For a deeper dive into specific recommendations, check out our guide on the best boat polishing compound. Just make sure whatever you choose is a marine-specific aluminum polish; they're formulated to handle the harsh saltwater environment.

When it comes to polishers, you’ll run into two main types: rotary and dual-action (DA). A rotary polisher spins on a single axis and can generate substantial heat and cutting power. It requires careful technique because holding it in one place or using excessive pressure can damage the finish or leave swirl marks.

For many boat owners, a dual-action (DA) polisher is the more forgiving option. A DA machine spins and oscillates in a random orbital pattern, which reduces concentrated heat buildup. Surface damage is still possible, so follow the tool and polish instructions, start with the least aggressive combination, and test a small area first.

The golden rule is to always start with the least aggressive product that can get the job done. If your boat just has some light hazing, you can likely skip the heavy cutting compound and start with a medium polish.

To really dial in your results, you have to pair the right liquid with the right polishing pad. Using a heavy cutting compound with a soft finishing pad won't do much, and vice versa. Here’s a quick guide to help you make the right choice.

Hull Condition Recommended Compound Type Recommended Pad Type Primary Goal
Heavy Oxidation, Pitting Heavy-Cut Compound Wool or Microfiber Cutting Pad Aggressively remove defects
Moderate Oxidation, Dullness Medium-Cut Compound/Polish Foam Cutting or Polishing Pad Restore shine, remove hazing
Light Haze, Minor Swirls One-Step Polish Foam Polishing Pad Refine the finish, add gloss
Near-Perfect Finish Finishing Polish or Glaze Foam Finishing Pad Maximize clarity and reflection

Think of this table as your cheat sheet. Find the description that best matches your boat's current state, and you'll have the perfect starting combination of compound and pad to bring that aluminum back to life.

Preparing Your Boat for a Perfect Polish

Clean aluminum boat and supplies ready for polishing preparation
A clean, dry hull gives polish a sound starting point.

Let’s be honest: you can't get a mirror finish on a dirty surface. This prep stage is the absolute, non-negotiable foundation for the whole project. Rushing it is the single biggest mistake I see, and it's what separates an amateur job from a truly showroom-quality result.

Think of it like painting a house. You’d never just slap a fresh coat over dirty, peeling walls, right? Same logic applies here.

First things first: a serious, thorough wash. Over a season, your boat collects a stubborn film of salt, algae, grime, and water spots that have to go. Before you even think about polishing, you have to get the surface perfectly clean. That includes learning how to safely remove stubborn water spots that can etch into the aluminum.

A powerful wash does more than just get the hull clean. It lifts away all the tiny abrasive particles that, if left behind, would get ground into the aluminum during polishing. That's how you end up with deep, frustrating scratches that are a nightmare to remove later.

A Deep Clean is Non-Negotiable

Start by giving the entire hull a deep scrub using a high-quality soap designed for marine environments. Our Better Boat Boat Soap is formulated to cut right through that tough grime and salt without stripping any protective coatings you might have.

Having everything you need in one place makes the scrub-down faster, so a complete boat cleaning kit is worth grabbing before you start.

Boat Exterior Cleaning Kit

Better Boat pick

Boat Exterior Cleaning Kit

Build a complete washdown setup in one box instead of piecing together soap, towels, sponge, eraser, and sprayer separately.

View product

Grab a soft-bristled brush and gently scrub the whole surface. Pay extra attention to the waterline, since that's where the worst buildup usually happens. Once you're done scrubbing, give the boat a complete rinse with fresh water and let it dry completely.

After the boat is clean, it's time to degrease, a critical step that far too many people skip. Engine exhaust, oils, and other gunk create a greasy film on the aluminum over time. Polish can't bond to or cut through that film, which leads to a splotchy, uneven mess.

A quick wipe-down with a good degreaser or even some isopropyl alcohol on a clean microfiber towel does the trick. This ensures your polishing compound makes direct contact with the aluminum oxide layer it's meant to work on. For a full walkthrough, check out our complete video guide on how to deep clean an aluminum boat.

Masking for Professional Results

Gloved hands masking boat trim before polishing the aluminum hull
Mask trim and hardware before the buffer comes out.

With the surface sparkling clean and totally degreased, your last prep task is masking off everything you don't want the polisher to touch. Trust me, a careless slip with a buffer can permanently scuff or damage non-metal surfaces in a split second.

Take your time with this. Use high-quality painter's tape to create a clean, protective border around these areas:

  • Vinyl decals and graphics: A spinning buffer pad will grab the edge of a decal and tear it right off before you can blink.
  • Painted trim and registration numbers: You want to protect these from accidental scuffs and abrasion.
  • Plastic or rubber components: Any non-aluminum trim pieces, like rub rails or cleats, should be carefully taped off.

This meticulous prep work helps create clean, crisp lines and protects the rest of your boat. It might feel a bit tedious, but this attention to detail is precisely what elevates the final outcome, ensuring all your hard work pays off with a flawless, professional shine.

For bare aluminum, a dedicated aluminum cleaner will pull off that built-up oxidation and salt residue before soap ever touches the hull.

With the hull sparkling clean, it’s time to play detective. Walk around the boat and run your hand over every inch of the surface. You're feeling for deep scratches, dings, or areas of heavy pitting that need extra attention.

When you find a spot, mark it with a small piece of painter's tape. This way, you won't forget where to focus during the compounding stage.

Now is also the perfect time to deal with any old, peeling decals or graphics you want gone. A quick blast with a heat gun or even a hairdryer will soften the adhesive, making them much easier to peel away. A dedicated adhesive remover will take care of any sticky gunk left behind.

Pro Tip: Don’t rush the inspection. Seriously. Identifying every little problem area now will save you from frustrating surprises later and is key to getting a uniform finish across the entire hull.

  • Antifouling Paint Line: Tape off the bottom paint to avoid scuffing it with the buffer.
  • Navigation Lights and Hardware: Cover any hardware you don’t plan on removing and polishing separately.

Executing The Polishing Process Like a Pro

With your boat perfectly prepped, this is where the real fun starts. The techniques you use from here on out will make the difference between a decent shine and a true, deep mirror finish. Think of it as a process of refinement, starting with the heavy lifting to remove years of neglect and finishing with a delicate touch to really make it pop.

Before you even think about grabbing a polisher, that foundational prep work is non-negotiable.

 

Gloved hands washing and masking an aluminum hull before polishing

 

This simple flow, wash, degrease, and mask, is everything. It gives you a clean canvas so the abrasive compounds can do their job properly. If you cut corners here, you're just fighting an uphill battle for the rest of the project.

Starting With Heavy Oxidation Removal

Wet sanding a heavily oxidized aluminum boat hull
Wet sanding levels severe oxidation before compounding.

If your hull looks chalky, dull, and forgotten, a standard polish isn't going to cut it. You need to get more aggressive to level out that damaged surface before you can even think about bringing out a shine. This is where wet-sanding comes into play.

Wet-sanding is really only for heavily oxidized or lightly pitted aluminum. It sounds intense, but it's just using very fine-grit waterproof sandpaper with plenty of water to knock down the worst of the damage.

I usually start with 800-grit and work my way up to 2000-grit. The key is to keep the surface soaking wet to stop the paper from clogging up and to help wash away the aluminum oxide you're removing.

Your goal here isn't a shine. You're aiming for a uniform, hazy finish. That haze is just a pattern of super-fine, consistent scratches that the next step, compounding, will easily buff out.

Wet-sanding is your reset button. It erases deep-seated oxidation that a buffer alone can't touch, creating a smooth, workable foundation. It’s extra work upfront, but trust me, it saves you hours of frustration with the polisher.

The First Cut: The Compounding Stage

Now we get to fire up the buffer. For this first pass, you'll want your most aggressive combination: a wool compounding pad and a good quality cutting compound. Wool pads just have more bite than foam, which is exactly what you need to erase those sanding marks or cut through stubborn oxidation.

Pro tip. Work in small sections with overlapping passes, and keep the pad moving. Wipe away black residue before it dries.

Squeeze a few small dabs of compound onto the pad. Pick a small, manageable 2x2 foot section to work on, because a larger area may let the compound dry before you can work it in. Set your variable-speed polisher to a low speed within the tool and product manufacturers' recommended range, just to spread the product evenly.

Once it's spread, increase the speed only as allowed by the tool, pad, and product instructions, then work the buffer across the section in slow, overlapping passes. Apply steady pressure within the tool manufacturer's guidance and keep the pad as flat as you can against the hull. This helps reduce buffer trails or "holograms" in the finish.

Flat buffer pad making overlapping passes across an aluminum hull
Flat, overlapping passes help produce an even finish.
  • Move Systematically: Work from top to bottom and overlap each pass by about 50%. This helps you avoid missing spots.
  • Keep it Moving: Don't ever let the buffer rest in one spot. It can generate enough heat to burn the aluminum, creating a permanent blemish.
  • Work Until It’s Clear: Keep buffing until the compound breaks down. You'll see it go from a hazy mess to almost clear. That's your cue to stop.

As soon as you finish a section, grab a clean microfiber towel and wipe off the black residue immediately. If you let that stuff dry, it's a real pain to get off later.

Refining The Finish With a Final Polish

After you've compounded the entire boat, it's going to look a thousand times better. But it's not a mirror finish, not yet. The wool pad and heavy compound have left their own tiny swirl marks behind. The final step is all about refining those away.

Switch to a much gentler setup: a soft foam finishing pad and a fine finishing polish. This combo has almost no cutting power. Its only job is to smooth out the microscopic scratches from the last stage and coax out that deep, liquid shine.

The technique is pretty much the same as compounding, but you'll use a much lighter touch.

  1. Apply a few pea-sized drops of finishing polish to your clean foam pad.
  2. Work in the same 2x2 foot sections, spreading the polish on a low speed.
  3. Bump the speed up a bit, but this time use only light to moderate pressure. You're letting the polish do the work, not forcing it.
  4. Overlap your passes and keep going until the polish turns almost transparent.
  5. Wipe the residue right away with a fresh, clean microfiber towel to reveal the shine underneath.

This two-step process, a heavy cut followed by a fine finish, is the secret sauce. It makes sure you properly remove all the damage first, then carefully polish the surface to a brilliant shine.

Soft foam pad refining the finish on an aluminum boat hull
A fine polish clears haze left by compounding.

Here's a crucial tip: before you even turn the polisher on, gently dab the pad across your 2x2 work area. This simple move "primes" the surface and stops the compound from slinging all over you and the boat the second the machine starts spinning.

Pro Tip: After you've made a few passes, stop the machine. Wipe the area clean with a good microfiber towel and hit it with a bright inspection light from a few different angles. This will instantly show you any lingering haze or oxidation you might have missed. Don't move on to the next section until this one looks perfect.

Between the cutting and refining stages, use a clean wipe-down to keep coarse compound residue away from the finishing pad.

For that wipe-down, grab a set of microfiber cloths so each pass pulls compound residue off cleanly.

If you leave any leftover cutting compound on the surface, it'll get picked up by your finishing pad and you'll just be grinding new, tiny scratches right back into your hard work.

Use one towel to get the bulk of the residue off, then grab a second, completely clean towel for the final buff. This two-towel method ensures you have a perfectly clean slate before moving to the final polishing phase.

Locking in the Shine with a Protective Sealant

You’ve put in some serious time and elbow grease to get that incredible mirror shine. The last thing you want is for it to vanish in a few weeks.

Without a protective barrier, freshly polished aluminum will start looking dull and chalky all over again as oxidation inevitably sets in. This final step isn't just a good idea, it's absolutely essential for preserving all your hard work.

Applying a high-quality sealant creates an invisible shield between the raw aluminum and the harsh marine environment. It blocks moisture, salt, and damaging UV rays from attacking the surface, effectively locking in the gloss and making your polish job last so much longer. It's the one thing that will keep your boat looking its best all season.

Choosing the Right Shield for Your Hull

When it comes to protectants, you’ve got options, from traditional carnauba waxes to modern synthetic formulas. Carnauba offers a beautiful, warm glow, but frankly, it just doesn't hold up in a demanding marine setting.

Synthetic sealants and ceramic-infused products offer far superior durability and protection. They're built for the abuse that comes with being on the water. To get a better sense of what's out there, you can explore our guide on what a ceramic sealant is and see the benefits for yourself.

For an aluminum boat, finish with a polish made for bare aluminum. Better Boat Marine Aluminum Polish uses an advanced polymer formula that adds UV protection and stain resistance to the polished surface. That helps limit sun-related dulling and makes future cleanups easier.

Applying a sealant is not a one-and-done task for the life of your boat. It's the beginning of a simple but crucial maintenance routine. Think of it as sunscreen for your hull; it needs to be reapplied to remain effective.

Application and Maintenance Schedule

Putting on Marine Aluminum Polish is about as straightforward as it gets. You can apply it by hand or with a buffer. By hand, use a clean applicator pad and work in a thin, even coat over a small section of the hull at a time. Gentle, circular motions are all you need.

Pro tip. Inspect the coating regularly and reapply it according to the product label. Saltwater use and sun exposure can shorten the interval.

Let it dry to a haze for a few minutes, then grab a clean, dry microfiber towel and buff it off. What you're left with is a slick, protected finish.

This protective layer is the key to long-term preservation. Many pros limit heavy abrasion to once every few years, instead relying on less aggressive polishing and frequent waxing to avoid thinning the alloy and preserve the boat's structural integrity.

Protective coating applied to a polished aluminum boat hull
Regular coating helps preserve polished aluminum with less abrasion.

For boats in high-UV or saltwater environments, inspect the coating regularly and reapply it according to the product label. Exposure and use conditions can shorten the maintenance interval.

Here’s a simple routine that will keep your boat looking great:

  • After Every Use: Give the hull a quick rinse with fresh water to get the salt off.
  • Monthly: Wash the boat with a pH-neutral boat soap. This gets rid of any grime buildup without stripping away your protective wax layer.
  • At the Label's Recommended Interval: Reapply marine wax or sealant as directed, adjusting for the boat's exposure and use.

Common Questions About Polishing Aluminum Boats

Even with the best guide in hand, questions always come up when you’re knee-deep in a project. Polishing an aluminum boat has a few quirks, and getting a quick answer can be a lifesaver. Let's tackle some of the most common things people ask.

Can I Use Automotive Polish on My Boat?

The short answer is no. Automotive polish is generally a poor match for bare aluminum.

Automotive polishes are designed for clear-coated paint, which is a completely different animal from the raw aluminum on your hull. They just don't have the aggressive abrasives needed to cut through that tough, chalky layer of aluminum oxide. You’ll end up with a hazy, disappointing finish and a lot of wasted effort.

Even more importantly, car products don’t contain the specialized corrosion inhibitors necessary to survive in a marine environment, especially saltwater.

How Do I Handle the Black Residue?

That messy, black gunk you see building up as you buff? It's totally normal. It's just a mix of used-up polish, the aluminum oxide you've removed, and microscopic bits of metal. The trick isn't to avoid it, but to manage it.

The best way to stay on top of it is to work in small, manageable sections, about 2x2 feet at a time. The moment you finish buffing an area, stop what you're doing and immediately wipe the residue away with a clean microfiber towel.

Pro Tip: Keep folding your microfiber towel to a clean side for every wipe. This simple habit stops you from smearing that grime right back onto your freshly polished surface, a classic rookie mistake that leads to hazing.

What Is the Best Way to Polish Tight Spots?

Small drill attachment polishing aluminum around a cleat and seam
Small attachments reach around cleats, rivets, and seams.

Your big orbital buffer is a beast on the large, flat sections of the hull, but it’s completely useless for the detailed areas. When you get to the tricky spots around rivets, cleats, seams, and tight corners, you'll need to change your approach.

For these spots, you have two great options.

  • By Hand: This is the most straightforward method. Dab a small amount of a good metal polish onto a microfiber applicator pad and work it into the area using firm, consistent pressure.
  • With a Drill: For a more professional result, grab a cone-shaped or ball-shaped polishing attachment for a standard power drill. This little tool lets you apply even speed and pressure in those small, awkward spaces, giving you a much more uniform shine across the whole boat.

Taking the time to do this detail work is what really separates a decent job from a fantastic one. It ensures every last inch of your boat has that brilliant, protected gleam you've been working so hard for.

At Better Boat, we know that having the right tools makes all the difference. Our premium marine-grade products are designed to give you professional results with less effort. Explore our full collection of cleaning and maintenance supplies to keep your vessel in top condition. Visit us at https://www.betterboat.com to find everything you need.

Can I Polish an Anodized Aluminum Boat?

This one's a big deal, and the answer is a firm no, you can't use abrasive polishes on an anodized finish.

Anodizing is essentially a tough, protective coating baked onto the aluminum. If you hit it with an aggressive compound, you'll chew right through that layer, leaving the raw metal exposed and vulnerable to the elements.

Gentle cleaning of an anodized aluminum rail on a boat
Gentle care protects the anodized layer from aggressive abrasion.

If your anodized aluminum is just grimy, a gentle wash is all it needs. Grab a soft brush and a pH-neutral soap, like our Better Boat Boat Soap, to get it clean without causing damage. For very light oxidation, you'll need to find a non-abrasive cleaner made specifically for anodized surfaces.

What If I Still See Swirl Marks After Polishing?

Seeing fine swirl marks after all that work can be frustrating, but don't sweat it. This is usually a sign that your last step was a bit too aggressive, either with the compound or the pad you used. It can also happen if you didn't get the surface perfectly clean between the cutting and polishing stages.

Don't panic, this is fixable. Just go back over the swirled areas with a finer finishing polish and a fresh, soft foam finishing pad. Use light pressure and slow, overlapping passes. You're gently burnishing the surface to erase those tiny scratches and bring back that flawless, mirror-like shine.

The pro tip to avoid this in the first place? Always use a separate, clean microfiber towel to wipe away residue after each step. This keeps the gritty particles from your cutting compound from getting dragged into your final polishing phase, which is a key part of the polishing aluminum boat process that separates a good job from a great one.

Quick quiz

Tap a question to see the answer.

Why should an aluminum hull be washed and degreased before polishing?

Cleaning removes grit, salt, grime, and oily film so the polishing compound can contact the oxidized aluminum without grinding debris into the surface. Premium Boat Wash Soap Concentrate

When is wet sanding appropriate for an aluminum boat?

It is reserved for heavily oxidized or lightly pitted bare aluminum that ordinary polishing cannot correct.

How should black residue be handled while buffing?

Work in small sections and wipe the residue away immediately with a clean side of a microfiber towel.